Vernon Rice Award for THE FANTASTICKS (1961)
Stockholm Critics Award for THE FANTASTICKS (1962)
ASCAP Award for Outstanding Country and Western Song for “My Cup Runneth Over” (1970)
Certificate of Appreciation, The City of New York honoring the
15th and 20th anniversaries of THE FANTASTICKS (1974 and 1979)
The Outer Critics Award for PHILEMON (1975)
The Jones and Schmidt Endowed Scholarship in Drama at the
University of Texas at Austin (1991)
Antoinette Tony Award honoring Excellence in the Theatre (1991)
Obie Award for THE FANTASTICKS (1991)
Special Antoinette Tony Award for THE FANTASTICKS (1992)
ASCAP-Richard Rodgers Award (1993)
Inducted into the Theater Hall of Fame (1998)
“Stars” were added to the Off-Broadway Walk of Fame outside the Lucille Lortel Theatre (1999)
Light Opera Works of Chicago Artistic Excellence Award for Lifetime Contribution to Musical Theater (2010)
Inducted into the Songwriter’s Hall of Fame (2012)
Honored with the Off-Broadway Alliance Living Legends inaugural award (2013)
Oscar Hammerstein Award for Lifetime Achievement (2017)
